 |
|
Letter to the editor - Priestly
misrepresents wild horse issue
Having
grown up the son of Montana cattle ranchers, I feel I know livestock
fairly well. But having also logged around 100 hours in and around wild
horse herds, I feel I know these animals equally well and disagree with
Frank Priestly's recent call for their demise.
Last month's bill that passed the house simply reinstates wild horses
from being slaughtered, a law in place since 1971. This law was
overturned after a Montana senator slipped a few paragraphs on the end
of a spending bill that allowed for the slaughter of American wild
horses for the first time in 34 years. There was no open debate on that
move; last month's House passage indeed allowed for debate on the House
floor and 78 Republicans voted to protect wild horses.
America's slaughtered wild and domestic horses are currently sent to
European dinner tables. With the exception of (shipping) fees charged by
American Airlines and (sales for) the company that ships the meat, there
is virtually no benefit to the American economy. Having personally
visited two of America's three horse slaughter plants, located in Texas,
I have seen city documents that cite them repeatedly for clogging the
city's sewer. The plants hire migrant Hispanic workers and operate in
poor neighborhoods. Most of the owners and workers live away from the
town in which they operate.
In other words, the horse slaughter industry is bad for the American
economy and good for undocumented immigrants and rich Europeans. Haven't
we done enough for the French?
In terms of numbers, the best government estimates put the number of
cattle on American public lands at over 4 million, with the number of
wild horses at around 35,000. I can personally attest to over-inflated
horse estimates in the five western herds I've documented in Montana,
Wyoming and Arizona.
Most Americans never see a wild horse in their lifetime. Both cattle and
horses are legally entitled to the land. There is a clear lack of
balance here.
As much as I enjoy a good steak, hunting, fishing and the American
farming and ranching way of life that I grew up with, I've grown tired
of those seeking to wipe out wild horses. It is my belief that Frank
Priestly and others like him haven't spent any time around these animals
or researching them, and that if they did, they might be a bit more
tolerant of the animal that got us out to the West in the first place.
Len Johnson, Tucson, Ariz.
Len Johnson recently completed a full-length documentary - "Last of the
Spanish Mustangs" - on wild horses. The documentary won the Southwest
Associated Press first place award for best documentary. To find out
more, visit lenjproductions.com.
Back to Endangered Animal News |